Toronto Finally Addressed Its Third-Line Centre Hole. It Cost a Goalie They Could Not Keep

The Maple Leafs have spent years trying to solve the same problem, and on July 1 they finally paid retail for an answer. Toronto acquired Nick Paul from Tampa Bay for goaltender Dennis Hildeby, a 2027 fourth-round pick and a 2028 third-rounder, and took on every dollar of his contract doing it.

That last part is not a footnote. The Lightning retained nothing, so Paul’s $3.15-million cap hit lands on Toronto’s books in full, with three years still to run. For a club that has treated its cap sheet like a minefield, absorbing an unretained middle-six contract with term is a statement about how badly the third-line centre spot needed filling.

Why Tampa was willing to move him

Paul did not fall off so much as get squeezed. The Lightning brought in Yanni Gourde to be their matchup centre, which left Paul bouncing around a lineup behind Brayden Point and Anthony Cirelli with no fixed job. His production followed the role down: seven goals and eight assists in 51 games in 2025-26, plus six playoff appearances. Those are not the numbers of a player a contender protects.

They are, however, the numbers of a player whose value is depressed by circumstance rather than decline, which is the kind of buy Toronto has historically been bad at making and needed to make here. Paul is 31, he is big, he can take defensive-zone starts, and he has played meaningful playoff hockey for a team that expected to win. If Toronto gives him the third-line centre job outright and leaves him there, the bet is that the version Tampa had in 2022 and 2023 is still available.

The Hildeby side was forced

The goaltending piece is the part that gets misread. Hildeby was not a throw-in Toronto happily surrendered. He posted an 8-10-4 record with a 2.98 goals-against average and a .904 save percentage and has two years left on his deal at an $841,667 cap hit through 2027-28, which is genuinely useful money for a third goalie.

The problem was waivers. As Maple Leafs Hotstove laid out, Hildeby no longer had a waiver exemption, meaning Toronto either risked losing him for nothing on the wire or carried three goaltenders on the NHL roster to keep him. Neither is a real option. Trading him into a deal that solved a forward problem was the best available exit, and Tampa knew Toronto’s alternatives were bad. Behind Anthony Stolarz, the organization is now leaning on Artur Akhtyamov as its next developmental piece in the crease.

What it means for Toronto’s number

Two picks and a fourth-string-adjacent goaltender for three years of a legitimate third-line centre is defensible on its own terms. The scepticism, if you have any, should sit on the term and the lack of retention. Toronto is paying $3.15 million through 2028-29 for a player whose last full season produced 15 points, and the Leafs do not have the cap flexibility to be wrong about that for long.

For anyone pricing Toronto this fall, the honest read is that this deal makes the bottom six deeper without changing the ceiling. The Maple Leafs did not get better at the top of the lineup on July 1. They got harder to play against on the third line, which is a smaller upgrade than the discourse around it suggested, and a real one all the same.

Odds and market references describe the situation at the time of writing. You must meet the legal gambling age in your province or territory. See responsible gambling.